What is the 3-bucket retirement strategy?

The 3-bucket strategy divides retirement assets by time horizon: Bucket 1 holds 1-2 years of expenses in cash and short-term reserves, Bucket 2 holds 3-10 years in bonds and income-producing assets, and Bucket 3 holds the remainder in equities for long-term growth. The goal is to never sell growth assets at a loss during a market downturn.

How is sequence-of-returns risk different from average return?

Two retirees can experience the same average annual return over their retirement and end up with very different outcomes. A market crash in years 1-3 of retirement is significantly more damaging than the same crash in years 20-23, because withdrawals during a depressed portfolio remove shares that would have compounded.

Which withdrawal strategy is best?

There is no single best strategy — each trades off certainty, longevity, and flexibility. Fixed dollar provides predictability but ignores markets. Fixed percentage adapts to portfolio size but creates volatile income. Guardrails (Guyton-Klinger) adjust within thresholds. Floor + upside guarantees a baseline. RMD-based ties withdrawals to IRS life-expectancy tables. The comparator on this page shows the trade-offs side-by-side.

What is the withdrawal guardrail rule?

Guardrail (Guyton-Klinger) withdrawals start at a target rate (often 4-5%) and adjust based on portfolio performance. If the current withdrawal rate rises above an upper guardrail (e.g., 6%), spending is cut by 10%. If it drops below a lower guardrail (e.g., 4%), spending is raised by 10%. This dynamic approach has historically supported higher initial withdrawal rates than fixed strategies.

Do I need to create an account to use this tool?

No — the planner runs entirely on the inputs you set with the sliders. Creating a free Praxion account is optional and unlocks saving your scenario, year-by-year tax-aware projections, RMD pressure analysis, and AI-driven nudges as markets move.

Retirement Income Planner: 3-Bucket + Withdrawal Comparator

Build a 3-bucket strategy, compare six withdrawal policies, and stress-test your plan against real-historical crashes. Runs on your inputs — no signup.

Jump to planner Full Praxion plan (free) — add Roth conversions, IRMAA timing, and sequencing →

Browser-only computation. No account required for this calculator; in-product plan adds tax + sequencing coordination.

3-bucket strategyIncome waterfall6 withdrawal policiesMonte Carlo stressSequence-of-returns lab

1. Tell us about your retirement

Move any slider — every chart on the page updates in real time. Your data stays in your browser.

Computing your income plan…

Want all of this bound to your real plan?

Sign up free to save your inputs, get year-by-year projections, RMD-aware tax planning, adaptive nudges when markets shift, and AI insights tailored to your portfolio — not a slider scenario.

Saved profile that updates as your accounts change
Personalized Roth conversion + withdrawal sequencing
Data Health score and shock-aware nudges
Monte Carlo stress against your full retirement horizon
AI Optimizer — strategy simulations applied with one tap

Save my inputs — free account Try the full dashboard

We’ll prefill these 6 values when you finish signup: retirement age, life expectancy, portfolio, expenses, Social Security, and pension. No credit card. We never sell your data.